A Review of the CD
"i'm not like this"
by The Malvinas


"i'm not like this"
by The Malvinas

Copyright 2002
3-Legged Dog Productions
P.O. Box 5004
Dallas, TX 75208-5004
ph: (214)335-6941
http://www.themalvinas.com and
mailto:info@themalvinas.com

This review is written by Kevin McCarthy, 9/02
"Kevin and Maxine’s Celtic & Folk Music CD Reviews"
http://www.kevindmccarthy.com/music/index.html
send me an email message

Well, I'm stumped. Malvina is not listed in my dictionary. So what does the name mean? Oh, I get it (after sneaking a peak at the web site of this group). In honor of the late folksinger and political activist Malvina Reynolds, Beth Cahill, Gina Forsyth and Lisa Markley, aka The Malvinas, have adopted her first name as the moniker for their threesome.

Do they do Reynolds justice? An unqualified yes.

These are three women who can write and deliver songs. Their initial effort encompasses most of the arc of human relationships--longing, seeking, settling, losing. You get the picture--none of these performers would list Mr. Rogers as an influence. If it's true that the truth sets us free, most of the characters in these songs haven't completely unshackled as yet.

But quite often there is a quirky twist.

Exhibit A: Gina Forsyth's "Home Of St. Francis." An individual is attracted to a young woman named Mary Lou and inexplicably misses the fact that the young woman in question is a nun. Might love truly be that blind? And yes, Forsyth closes the song with "tell her hello Mary Lou, good-by heart."

In "Maria," all take turns singing about an alternative religious emissary:

"...mama mia avo
rosary beads rattle soft and low
the temple veil's fallen down
can't go to father, fear the son...

...she'll intercede, say a prayer for me
maria, maria, maria
lady at the gate, take us in the back way..."

"Sun Salutation," lays out the remnants of a failed relationship, with an obliquely optimistic message:
"...tell you don't even try
to make sense of this mess
just clutch your flag and hold it high

as you greet the sun in the east
lay your grief to the west
empty yourself of all the rest
the earth will spin..."

The limb all artists climb out on is portrayed in "Everyone's An Artist." A singer is playing at 2 a.m., with just the bartender in attendance:
"...the lights have been up a good fifteen minutes
she's just hoping I'll quit
but I'm not tired and I'm thirsty
I've got a following you just can't see it..."
Forsyth provides ironic humor, reminiscent of Cheryl Wheeler, with "Like This." After an apparently not-so-simple kiss turns her into a gooey state, she worriedly sings of her condition but then comes to embrace it:
"...years of education
now it's all a muddle
years of psychotherapy
turned into a puddle...

...will it always be like this?
please tell me I don't have to go
will it always be like this?
God, I surely hope so..."

Both Markley's sultry "Resonate" and Cahill's "Sepia Tone" pinpoint the affirmation so often needed by one person of another.

The subject matter of this release may be somewhat somber but the quality of the artistry makes this an attractive release. Add in some touches of humor and there's no excuse for failing to pick up this CD. Malvina, they've done you right.

The Malvinas are Gina Forsyth on vocals, fiddle and guitar; Lisa Markley on vocals, guitar, dobro and percussion and Beth Chaill on vocals, tenor guitar and mandolin. Martin McCall on drums and Andy Chiles on bass assisted on this release.

Track List:


Copyright © 1998-2015 Kevin & Maxine’s Celtic & Folk Music CD Reviews. All rights reserved.

Ownership, copyright and title of this folk music CD review belongs to me, Kevin McCarthy. Ownership, copyright and title are not transferable or assignable to you or other parties regardless of how or if you or other parties use, copy, save, backup, store, retrieve, transmit, display, publish, modify or share the CD review in whole or in part. Please read the "Terms, Conditions and Disclaimer" section on my web site for additional information about using, quoting, or reprinting this CD review.

Send inquiries to: send me an email message.

Return to Kevin and Maxine’s Celtic & Folk Music CD Reviews home page.

To return to the last web page you visited, click the "Back" button that appears immediately below: