A Review of the CD
"The Man From God Knows Where"
by Tom Russell

"The Man From God Knows Where"
by Tom Russell

Copyright 1999
Hightone Records
220 4th Street #101
Oakland, CA 94607
ph: (510)-763-8500
fax: (510)-763-8558

This review is written by Kevin McCarthy, 3/99
"Kevin and Maxine’s Celtic & Folk Music CD Reviews"
send me an email message

"I'm an American Primitive man, in an American Primitive land...American Primitive Man." Tom Russell's mantra-like archetype sears its way into the psyche as he employs his family's genealogy and emigration from Ireland and Scandinavia to America in a larger-than-life visceral spectre barely contained by this release.

The entire Russell family tree is unerringly depicted--from the old growth to Charlie Russell, Tom's father, from those who blossomed and bloomed to those stunted by the foibles of humanity, all in a panorama structured as a heterogeneous montage of mankind.

This epochal work is not history sanitized and agreed upon by an educational committee or publishing house. Rather, it is humanity captured in all its shapes and sizes, delivering the joys and sorrows, and sacrifices and hardships endured in the pursuit of a better life.

Russell has cannily brought in Iris Dement, Dolores Keane, Dave Van Ronk and Norwegians Sondre Bratland and Kari Bremnes as additional vocalists lending authenticity to this tableau of tales. Dement brings an emotional edge to "Wayfarin' Stranger" while Dolores Keane's smoky vocals on "Mary Clare Malloy" and "When Irish Girls Grow Up" are tear-inducing.

Van Ronk almost steals the show as he adds humor and raunchiness with his cackling, growling portrayal of the underbelly of the family lineage--the outcastes. He sings:

"...I'm yer inbred brother that was kept inside a shed
I'm the cross-eyed little stutterer who always wet the bed
I'm yer queer Uncle Harry, yer retarded brother Fred...

...I've embarrassed folks at weddings
I'm the cur who passed out face down in your anniversary cake
I'm the Black Sheep, the Philanderer, the Louse, the Souse, the Rake
The Remittance man, the Snake-the bloody outcaste..."

Bretland and Bremnes offer genuine and moving depictions of the Norwegian side of Russell's roots, bringing to life the stories, triumphs and tragedies of the innumerable Scandinavian emigrants who settled in the Midwest.

Russell's underrated vocals also deserve special mention. His ability to strike just the right nuance and reach the emotional timbre needed throughout this release is remarkable.

Choosing to close out on an upbeat note, he duets with Dement in touchingly wrapping up this powerful chronicle with the tender and optimistic "Love Abides":

Russell has aimed large with this release and deserves immense credit for both doing so and succeeding. This concept album demonstrably realizes the awesome power possible in the fusion of words and music, and Russell has indeed written some soul-shaking lyrics here. "The Man From God Knows Where" is simply a great achievement and the best release so far in 1999. Perhaps, with this production, Russell will receive the recognition he so belatedly deserves. The acknowledgement of his talent has too long been missing, due to the inability to pigeonhole him to a specific music genre.

One other important note to be made is that hearing single or even several cuts from this album does not do it justice. Like a great book, the scope and full effect of this production is incomplete and diminished unless it is experienced in its entirety.

The liner notes deserve special mention: Russell has assembled a 14-page booklet, bounded by twine, twice the size of typical liner notes that are too large for enclosure in any jewel box. He provides the expected song lyrics but also includes family pictures and photographs of historical events and figures. This is a collector's item.

Besides the all-star cast of vocalists, Russell is also backed by Annbjorg Lien on hardanger fiddle and Swedish nyckelharpa; Andrew Hardin on rhythm, lead acoustic and electric guitars; Jorund Bageberg on bass; Anders Engen on drums; Hank Bones on trumpet and trombone; Knut Riersrud on lead guitar, Weisseborn Hawaiian lap steel, banjo, resphonic guitar, doro, and harmonica; and Eoin O'Riabhaigh on uillean pipes and tin whistle.

Track List:

All songs by Tom Russell unless as noted.

Copyright © 1998-2015 Kevin & Maxine’s Celtic & Folk Music CD Reviews. All rights reserved.

Ownership, copyright and title of this folk music CD review belongs to me, Kevin McCarthy. Ownership, copyright and title are not transferable or assignable to you or other parties regardless of how or if you or other parties use, copy, save, backup, store, retrieve, transmit, display, publish, modify or share the CD review in whole or in part. Please read the "Terms, Conditions and Disclaimer" section on my web site for additional information about using, quoting, or reprinting this CD review.

Send inquiries to: send me an email message.

Return to Kevin and Maxine’s Celtic & Folk Music CD Reviews home page.

To return to the last web page you visited, click the "Back" button that appears immediately below: